Impact Windows Vs. Traditional Windows: A Cost-Benefit Analysis

Impact windows are specially designed to withstand strong winds and debris during severe weather conditions, offering an added layer of protection for your home. Traditional windows, on the other hand, may not hold up as well during hurricanes or storms, putting your property at risk of damage and your family at risk of injury.Choosing the right type of window is crucial for ensuring the safety and security of your home, as well as optimizing energy efficiency. By investing in impact windows, you can not only protect your property during extreme weather events but also reduce energy costs by minimizing heat loss and air leakage.

Understanding Impact Windows

Impact windows are specially designed windows that are constructed using multiple layers of shatter-resistant glass and a durable frame that is designed to withstand high winds and flying debris during a hurricane. These windows are reinforced with a plastic interlayer that helps them withstand impact, preventing the glass from breaking into sharp, dangerous shards. The specific features that make impact windows a preferable choice in hurricane-prone areas include their ability to protect homes from damage, increase energy efficiency, and provide added security against intruders.

Understanding Traditional Windows

Traditional windows are typically made of wood or aluminum frames and have single or double-hung sashes that can be opened vertically. Common types of traditional windows used in homes include casement windows, bay windows, and picture windows, each offering different functionalities and aesthetics.

  1. Casement windows are hinged at the side and open outward, providing good ventilation and a clean, modern look.
  2. Bay windows, which project outward from the home and create a nook inside, are popular for adding architectural interest and natural light.
  3. Picture windows are large, fixed windows that do not open and are ideal for showcasing panoramic views and bringing in natural light.

Traditional windows come in a variety of materials, finishes, and styles to suit different home designs and preferences. They can be customized with features like grids, tinted glass, and decorative hardware to enhance the overall look of a home. Whether looking for a classic appearance or a modern twist, traditional windows offer both functionality and aesthetic appeal to enhance any home’s interior and exterior design.

Cost Analysis

The upfront costs of impact windows are typically higher than traditional windows due to the reinforced construction and specialized materials needed for impact resistance. However, in the long term, impact windows can save money on maintenance and replacement costs, as they are more durable and less likely to break in extreme weather conditions. Traditional windows may require more frequent maintenance and replacement due to damage from storms or accidents, potentially costing more in the long run.

Benefits of Impact Windows

Installing impact-resistant windows and doors can enhance safety during severe weather, while also potentially reducing insurance premiums due to the decreased risk of damage. Additionally, these windows also provide increased energy efficiency and noise reduction, leading to lower utility bills and a more peaceful environment. The added protection and energy efficiency can also boost the property’s value, making it a smart investment in both safety and financial return.

Limitations of Traditional Windows

Traditional windows offer little protection during storms, leaving homes vulnerable to damage from strong winds and flying debris. Homeowners may need to invest in costly storm shutters to minimize the risk of window breakage during extreme weather events. Additionally, the increased risk of damage from storms could result in higher insurance premiums for those with traditional windows.

Case Studies or Examples

John and Jane Smith of Miami, Florida, were tired of constantly boarding up their windows during hurricane season. After installing impact windows, they expressed, “We no longer have to worry about flying debris shattering our windows, and we feel much safer in our home now.”

Sarah, a homeowner in Florida, installed impact windows to protect her home from hurricanes. She shared, “After our area was hit by a major storm, I was so relieved to see that our impact windows held up against the strong winds and flying debris. Our home remained safe and secure, and I know we made the right choice in investing in impact windows.”

Making the Decision

When choosing between impact and traditional windows, homeowners should consider factors such as location, budget, and desired level of security. Impact windows are ideal for homes in hurricane-prone areas, as they provide increased protection against debris and high winds. Additionally, impact windows can offer energy efficiency benefits and increased noise reduction compared to traditional windows.

To help with the decision-making process, homeowners can create a checklist that includes questions such as: Is the home located in a high-risk hurricane zone? What is the budget for window replacement? What level of security and energy efficiency is desired? By evaluating these factors and consulting with a professional, homeowners can make an informed decision on whether impact or traditional windows are the best choice for their home.


In conclusion, impact windows offer superior protection against storms, intruders, and UV rays, making them a wise long-term investment for homeowners. Not only do impact windows provide peace of mind and increased property value, but they also offer potential savings on insurance premiums and energy costs. Contact Broward Impact today for a consultation to learn more about how impact windows can benefit your home in the long run.

Protect your home and loved ones by upgrading to impact windows for increased safety and security. Not only will you have peace of mind during severe weather, but you’ll also enjoy enhanced energy efficiency and reduced noise pollution. Take the first step towards a more secure and comfortable home today by scheduling a consultation with our experts.

Get Your Free In-Home Estimate!

Don't wait for the next hurricane to protect your home. The BEST time is now...
back to top